Fine Dining Restaurants for a Romantic Night Out in Key Largo

As the first island of the Florida Keys, Key Largo is known for its relaxed atmosphere and stunning beaches. Whether you’re escaping to Key Largo for a romantic getaway or to simply unwind, you’ll be pleased to know there are several fine dining restaurants in the area you can enjoy. On your next trip, make plans to check out a few of these top options.

Marker 88

Enjoy a glass of wine from one of the best wine lists in the area as you take in the lovely sunset at Marker 88. When you’re ready to order, the broiled Florida lobster, yellowtail meunière, and organic chicken Florentine are all popular menu choices. For dessert, you won’t want to miss the opportunity to enjoy the homemade Key lime pie.

Atlantic’s Edge Restaurant

Take a seat at the indoor or outdoor dining area at Atlantic’s Edge Restaurant, and you’ll enjoy panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean. If you stop by for dinner, you can begin your meal with steamed Maine mussels or a meat and cheese board. For your main course, you can’t go wrong with the roasted pineapple chicken, jumbo lump crab cakes, or guava-glazed mahi. If you saved room for dessert, the Key lime tart is a treat to savor.

Old Tavernier Restaurant

Located right on the water, Old Tavernier Restaurant is an island mainstay for fine Greek and Italian cuisine. If you’re in the mood for pasta, consider the manicotti or Fettuccine Alfredo with ham and scallions. The chicken and shrimp al mare, which comes in a wine, shallot, and cream sauce served over pasta, is also an excellent dish to try. Other popular dishes at the restaurant include the Greek style whole yellowtail, petit filet with shrimp, and shrimp scampi.


Pierre’s is a romantic restaurant located directly on the beach that serves gourmet cuisine from around the world to go along with the stunning sunsets. Consider ordering the seafood curry, which comes with Florida lobster, Key West pink shrimp, and sea scallops cooked in a Thai coconut curry sauce. Use Hotel Planner to search for Key Largo hotels near Pierre’s, and you won’t have to worry about indulging in another glass of wine from the extensive French and American wine list because you can simply walk back to your room.

Sol by the Sea

At Sol by the Sea, you’ll find a rustic yet romantic restaurant that sits on the edge of a pier overlooking the sparkling blue waters around Key Largo. Sit down on one of the driftwood benches at the whitewashed tables and find a menu that offers excellent seafood selections. You can start your meal with the clam and conch chowder or ahi tuna poke. For your main course, consider the crispy lobster that comes with mango rum butter, a green papaya and mango slaw, and grilled asparagus.

From fresh Florida seafood to gourmet international cuisine, when you’re looking for the best fine dining in Key Largo, you don’t want to miss the selections available at these top restaurants.